• About Kathy Shaidle
  • Kathy Shaidle: Donate
  • Kathy Shaidle: Privacy policy

5 Feet of Fury

Kathy Shaidle's blog. Est. 2000

Unsettled science: progressive hero Stephen Jay Gould was wrong about skulls and race

June 15, 2011 By Kathy Shaidle

Ooops:

In a 1981 book, “The Mismeasure of Man,” the paleontologist Stephen Jay Gould asserted that Morton, believing that brain size was a measure of intelligence, had subconsciously manipulated the brain volumes of European, Asian and African skulls to favor his bias that Europeans had larger brains and Africans smaller ones.

But now physical anthropologists at the University of Pennsylvania, which owns Morton’s collection, have remeasured the skulls, and in an article that does little to burnish Dr. Gould’s reputation as a scholar, they conclude that almost every detail of his analysis is wrong. (…)

Dr. Gould did not measure any of the skulls himself but merely did a paper reanalysis of Morton’s results. He accused Morton of various subterfuges, like leaving out subgroups to manipulate a group’s overall score. When these errors were corrected, Dr. Gould said, “there are no differences to speak of among Morton’s races.”

But Dr. Gould himself omitted subgroups in his own reanalysis, and made various errors in his calculations.

When these are corrected, the differences between the racial categories recognized by Morton are as he assigned them.

“Ironically, Gould’s own analysis of Morton is likely the stronger example of a bias influencing results,” the Pennsylvania team writes.

***
His wife is a real peach, too.

PLUS (as we’ve discussed earlier this week) — “Never underestimate a man’s ability to lie for a good cause”:

Yes! ‘Head size is correlated with cold weather’…but then so is IQ. (…)

This is hardly the first time an anthropologist has lied in the name of equality…

Two of the major superstitions of our time are the notion that man is merely a blank slate whose behavior is merely the product of the social environment and its sister, that race doesn’t exist. Yet one by one, the pseudo-scientific sources of these myths are being discredited by serious scientists, and last week, one of the biggest sources of all took a nose dive.

Franz Boas, often called the grandfather of modern anthropology and a pioneer pusher of the idea that race is not a very meaningful concept, merely a “social construct” not found in nature, probably ranks with Karl Marx and Sigmund Freud as one of the most influential thinkers of the modern age.

But it now turns out that Boas himself was guilty of no small degree of unscientific blunder—and maybe even fraud. (…)

In political terms, if human beings have few or no “fixed characters” and are shaped by the social environment, then what we know as modern liberalism is in business. So is communism, which also assumes that human beings can be transformed by manipulating the social environment.

It’s no accident that Boas was a lifelong sympathizer of Marxism.

Unfortunately, for the social and human engineers, the study has now been shown to be invalid.

More from my site

  • ‘Race, IQ and Wealth: What the facts tell us about a taboo subject’‘Race, IQ and Wealth: What the facts tell us about a taboo subject’
  • The one you’ve been waiting for: Sailer responds to ‘Foreign Policy’s debunking of ‘IQ and the Wealth of Nations’The one you’ve been waiting for: Sailer responds to ‘Foreign Policy’s debunking of ‘IQ and the Wealth of Nations’
  • Sailer calls Watson “a modern Galileo”Sailer calls Watson “a modern Galileo”
  • ‘Stephen Jay Gould: Bully and Boob’‘Stephen Jay Gould: Bully and Boob’

Filed Under: conservative blog

« NEW time, date, location for Toronto JDL protest against ‘Sea Hitler’ Gaza Boat
21st century ‘Prufrock’: do I dare to eat a… banana…? »
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter


Ebates.ca

RSS my husband’s blog

  • DC Comics pulls plug on Jesus comic series after over 230,000 people complain
  • Scott Adams: ‘How Long Before We See Trump Derangement Syndrome Used as a Legal Defense?’
  • Dear Qallunaat (white people)
  • Continental Breakfast
  • Thinking about Cultural Appropriation
  • Rep. Omar’s Anti-Semitism is Just CAIR’s Anti-Semitism
  • ‘Some Really Stupid People’: Our Catastrophically Clueless Congress
  • 15 Celebrities Who Blamed Trump, Deplorables for Hoax Attack on Jussie Smollett
  • Twilight of the Oligarchs?
  • Rift Between Trump and Europe Is Now Open and Angry

Archives

Copyright © 2019 · Magazine Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in