• About Kathy Shaidle
  • Kathy Shaidle: Donate
  • Kathy Shaidle: Privacy policy

5 Feet of Fury

Kathy Shaidle's blog. Est. 2000

Joseph Bottum looks at a bunch of recent books about anarchism

August 30, 2013 By Kathy Shaidle

Christianity Today:

The people at Occupy Wall Street were the return of the Levellers and Diggers, lifted straight out of the 17th century—albeit with the explicit religion of those old Christian movements shed along the way. (Except for a pair of elderly peace activists trying to start a prayer circle, everyone I interviewed described Christianity in general, and Catholicism in particular, as a major source of the evil they had set out to oppose.) (…)

The enthusiasm, spontaneity, and creativity” of a “cascading social movement,” he notes, can run “far ahead of the organizations wishing to represent, coordinate, and channel it.” And, in an interesting and probably accurate reinterpretation of received history, he dismisses the mainstream organizations that emerged out of the civil-rights struggle in the 1960s as merely the groups with the best public-relations teams—the ones that successfully sold themselves as leaders to a media desperate for an intelligible, hierarchical account with which to understand what was going on.

The real civil rights movement, Scott argues, was much wilder, much woollier, and much wackier. Much more like what anarchists want. (…)

Perhaps it’s worth noticing that the most interesting proposals for Christian Anarchism, from Simone Weil to Wendell Berry, are usually rural, usually agrarian—while the canonical writings of Anarchism, from Pierre-Joseph Proudhon to Emma Goldman, are essentially urban. The Occupy movement occurred entirely in cities, of course, and so it seems natural that its theorists have turned to those urban texts.

***
Arguably, the two most enduring anarchist(ic) “groups” in history have both been Christian — and urban: the Catholic Worker movement, and Alcoholics Anonymous.

More from my site

  • Virtual Capitalism 101: a series by Saul RothbartVirtual Capitalism 101: a series by Saul Rothbart
  • Antoine on Chick-fil-A: ‘The more research I do, the more the gay people look like asses’ (video)Antoine on Chick-fil-A: ‘The more research I do, the more the gay people look like asses’ (video)
  • In other words, they were lazy drunksIn other words, they were lazy drunks
  • Ain’t the pro-life movement grand?Ain’t the pro-life movement grand?

Filed Under: conservative blog

« UK: ‘Now it’s the turn of [football] fans who sing homophobic songs to face prosecution’
Talk Radio Watch: Weekly recap of conservative talk radio highlights »
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter


Ebates.ca

RSS my husband’s blog

  • Canadian Province to Shut Down China’s Confucius Institute
  • Canadian who tried to join terrorists out of prison after less than two years despite “high risk to public safety”
  • German police lose ALL the evidence against two paedophiles who allegedly raped more than 30 children at least 1,000 times at rundown campsite
  • Continental Breakfast
  • ‘Kill his daughter, son-in-law. Kill ’em all’ – Muslim charged in jihad plot threatened Trump children
  • UK: Only one in 10 jihadis returning from Syria prosecuted, figures reveal
  • Rachel Riley threatens legal action against Twitter users following anti-Semitism row
  • To Target Israel, Iran’s ‘Suitcase’ GPS Kits Turn Hezbollah Rockets Into Guided Missiles
  • A pro-refugee sign popular among progressives has troubling origins.
  • Jussie Smollett, and the strange alchemy of egalitarian despotism

Archives

Copyright © 2019 · Magazine Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in